Splitting the Farm Between Your Children: Why Equal Isn’t Always Fair 

Fair and equal are not the same thing when it comes to the family farm. Dividing the land into equal shares between your children often forces a sale or leaves the farm too small to run. A fair plan usually gives the child working the farm the operating assets and looks after the others another way, with off-farm assets, insurance or a staged payment. The goal is to protect the farm and the family at the same time.

“How do I make this fair between the kids without destroying everything?” 

If you farm and you have more than one child, that question has probably kept you up at night. You love them the same. You want to do right by all of them. And you can feel that one wrong move could cost you the farm, the family, or both. 

The way through starts with one idea that changes everything. 

Fair and Equal Are Not the Same Thing 

Equal means everyone gets the same. Three children, three equal shares. It sounds fair, and on a spreadsheet it looks fair. But a farm is not a bank account. You cannot cut a working farm into equal pieces without often breaking the thing that makes it work. 

Fair means everyone is looked after in a way that makes sense for their life and their contribution. The child who has poured twenty years into the place is in a different position from the child who visits at Christmas. Treating them identically can feel like the opposite of fair to the one who stayed. 

The families who navigate this well stop asking how to split it equally and start asking how to treat everyone fairly while keeping the farm whole. It is a very different question, and it has much better answers. 

Why an Equal Split Can Break the Farm 

Say you leave the land to all three children in equal shares and hope they will sort it out. Here is what often happens. 

The children off the farm need to realise their share, and the only way to do that is to sell. The on-farm child cannot afford to buy them out at full market value, because the farm’s wealth is in land, not cash. So the farm goes on the market, or the family ends up in a dispute that drags on for years. An equal split on paper can quietly guarantee the farm does not survive the generation. 

Even where nobody wants a sale, joint ownership between siblings who want different things is a recipe for deadlock. One wants to reinvest, one wants income, one wants out. Shared ownership without a clear structure is one of the most common ways a family farm comes apart. 

What Fair Actually Looks Like 

A fair plan usually separates the farm from the fairness. The child running the farm gets a workable operation. The others are looked after another way. That keeps the business intact under one clear decision maker, and still recognises every child. 

It also helps to separate ownership from management. The on-farm child can be given control of the operation and a clear path to owning the working assets, while other children hold an interest in value without a say in the daily running. If several children genuinely want to farm, that is its own conversation, and we cover it in our piece on farm succession with more than one child involved. 

The Equalisation Toolkit 

If the on-farm child keeps the working land, how do you look after the others fairly? There are more options than most families realise, and the right mix depends on your situation. 

Off-farm assets, such as superannuation, a second property, shares or cash, can balance things up. Life insurance can create a pool of money to pass to the non-farming children without touching the land. A separate, non-working block or an ongoing income stream can go to the off-farm children instead of a slice of the operating farm. And the transition can be staged over time so it does not all fall on one event. 

None of these are right for everyone. What matters is that you choose deliberately, value things honestly, and write it down. A plan the whole family understands is worth far more than a plan that only looks even on paper. 

It Starts With the Conversation 

The hardest part of fair versus equal is rarely legal. It is the conversation. Most succession disputes start with an assumption nobody said out loud. What each child wants. What fair means to them. Who expects what. 

Have that conversation early and openly, before expectations harden. When children understand the reasoning, that the on-farm sibling is not being favoured but is taking on a business and a lifetime of work, fair usually feels fair. When it is sprung on them in a will, it rarely does. 

Put it in Writing
Case Study: Balancing Fairness Without Selling the Farm

Parents with three children, one on the farm and two in the city, wanted to be fair without forcing a sale. We helped structure a plan that gave the on-farm child the operating land and a clear path to ownership, and balanced the others with off-farm assets and an interest in a separate block. Rather than leave it as a surprise in a will, the parents sat all three children down and walked them through the reasoning, that the daughter on the farm had worked it for years for modest wages and was taking on a business, not just an asset, and that the two in the city were being looked after in a way that reflected their lives off the land. The on-farm daughter took over the operating land through the family structure and knew exactly how and when full ownership would pass to her. The other two received superannuation, an investment property and a non-working block that could be leased for income or sold if they chose, without touching the farming country. Because everyone heard the same plan at the same time and it was documented, there were no assumptions left to curdle into resentment. When the parents eventually stepped back, the handover was calm and the three of them were still speaking, still a family. Fair, in the end, was not identical shares. It was a plan everyone understood. 

Case Study: When Equal Didn’t Lead to Fair 

Another family split everything equally in a will, assuming the children would work it out. When the time came, the off-farm children needed their share and the farm had to be sold. On paper it looked scrupulously fair, a third each. In practice, the son who had stayed and run the farm could not raise anywhere near enough to buy out his two siblings at full market value, because the wealth was all in land and there was very little cash. His siblings, with mortgages and families of their own, were not in a position to simply gift their shares back. With no structure and no plan to bridge the gap, the only way to give each child their equal third was to put the property on the market. The son lost the farm he had built his life around, the sale happened in a soft market and realised less than hoped, and the fallout left the siblings barely speaking. An equal split on paper had guaranteed an unequal and painful result. Had the parents planned it while they were alive, giving the on-farm son the operating land and balancing the others with off-farm assets and a staged payment, the same wish to be fair could have kept the farm in the family and the family intact. Equal was easy to write. Fair took a plan. 

Fair, Workable and Written Down 

You cannot make everyone identical, and you should not try. You can be fair, keep the farm workable, and protect the relationships, all at once. It takes an honest conversation, the right structure, and a plan that is written down rather than assumed. This is not just a legal issue. It is about keeping your family together. 

If you are wrestling with fair versus equal, start now, while everyone is calm and you still have options. Protect your farm, secure your legacy and keep what you have built in the family. 

Three steps you can take now
  1. Get clear on the real picture. List the land, the entities, the off-farm assets and who actually wants to farm.
  2. Start the conversation with all your children before anything is locked in.
  3. Build a fair, workable plan with a specialist agribusiness lawyer, and write it down.
Protect your farm. Secure your legacy. Keep your family together.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Equal means every child receives the same share. Fair means each child is looked after appropriately for their situation and contribution. On a working farm an equal split often forces a sale, so a fair plan usually treats the farming and non-farming children differently. 

Usually the child running the farm keeps the working land and operation, while the others are balanced with off-farm assets, life insurance, a separate block or an income stream. The aim is to keep the farm workable while still looking after everyone. 

Because a farm cannot be divided like cash. If the off-farm children need their share, the on-farm child often cannot buy them out, so the farm has to be sold. Equal shares between siblings who want different things also lead to deadlock. 

Common options include off-farm assets such as superannuation or shares, life insurance proceeds, a separate property, or a staged payment over time. The right mix depends on your assets and should be valued honestly and documented. 

Plan early, have an honest conversation about expectations before anything is set, separate ownership from management, and put the plan in writing. Most disputes come from silence and assumptions, not the plan itself. 

As early as possible, while everyone is calm and you still have options. Leaving it until a death or illness forces the issue takes the decision out of your hands and makes conflict far more likely. 

Author: Skye Tyrwhitt

 

Skye Tyrwhitt is a Principal Solicitor at Lovett & Green and is widely recognised as one of New South Wales’ leading water law practitioners. She works closely with farmers, landowners, and agribusiness clients across regional NSW, advising on rural property transactions, water access licences, and succession planning.

 

She has extensive experience across rural, residential, and commercial conveyancing, with particular expertise in water rights and complex land arrangements. Skye is known for delivering clear, practical advice and achieving outcomes that reflect her clients’ long-term goals. 

 

Skye holds a Diploma of Law from the University of Sydney and a Graduate Diploma of Legal Practice from the College of Law. Skye has also been recognised by Doyles Guide as a Recommended Agribusiness Lawyer. 

Disclaimer: This article is intended to provide general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every situation is different, and you should obtain advice specific to your circumstances before making any decisions. If you would like tailored guidance, we encourage you to get in touch with our team at [email protected] or book your free appointment now.

Like this article?

Scroll to Top